107 Comments
User's avatar
Ernie Brill's avatar

P,S. I may never look at onions the same way. In that sense, this story is truly a cut ( and more than one ) above the rest.It is also cool that no one in the story is sure about her sexual identity.

Expand full comment
Ernie Brill's avatar

A beautiful. taut warm story with that hardnose lowkey different kind of semibravado. You have also always had the gift to make people cry ( with or without onions, and even if some of us are not among the brighter bulbs but also do have tulips). And the writing is so deft with that ultra solid swish jump shot on a court where the hoops are metalchains and when you're in the zone ( free parking) although the chains are metal you can barely hear the swish. That's when it' best to be on the net.

Expand full comment
camden noir's avatar

So fun to read. Kept my interest the whole time and I audibly laughed at least thrice. Great job!

Expand full comment
Georgena Felicia's avatar

Nothing like an onion cry - good cover up for tears about "something else; tears long bottled up; good release what has been "damned" up. Just good all the way around!

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank you.

Expand full comment
Karlynn Moller's avatar

Ooof. Again, tears and laughter in the same short story. I’ve been the cop, the night person, the one escaping reality by reading, the one with secret, unspoken loves, the abused partner. The human experience is such a diverse, crazy broad expanse....yet, so much common emotion. Pain. We all feel it. Different reasons. Different degrees. But, those small pains.......like a sliver you just can’t grasp with the tweezers. You forget it is there for awhile until the smallest thing reminds you it never left.

Expand full comment
Jack Haynes's avatar

Absolutely loved this. Economical with words. Extravagant with heart.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank you, Jack.

Expand full comment
yvonne's avatar

How many travel routes have you plotted, always knowing they will be discarded? I plot them daily. They give me hope. I know that there is still something else, something more maybe than what is.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

It's a fictional story but the fictional town is based on a real mining town where two rural highways intersect.

Expand full comment
Jeff Hartzer's avatar

in All Ways astonished

that you ‘reply’ at all. Continued thanks for your generosity.

Though not a single Indian in whole series, so moved by recent binge-ing of Six Feet Under 2001-06. We have so fallen back into beyond the last millennium on human rights…rare to see a tough to like bi-polar character.

Expand full comment
LeighK's avatar

And one final PS: Edward Hopper Nighthawks meets Sherman Alexie’s graveyard shift. Over and out.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

I hadn't made that connection!

Expand full comment
LeighK's avatar

I just read this again. There’s so much happening in it. I can see it feel it and taste it. I’m being effusive (is that a distant cousin of impulsive?) but this story is so damn rich.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank you, Leigh.

Expand full comment
LeighK's avatar

PS. I just listened to the audio version. Even better!

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thanks!

Expand full comment
LeighK's avatar

Fantastic - it was like watching a film but better. So many simple sentences that encapsulated complex feelings beautifully. Still - it would make a great film- short or otherwise.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thanks, Leigh! A short film? Now you got me pondering that...

Expand full comment
Jeff Hartzer's avatar

I am glad that I waited for a perfect moment to read this story. So many accolades for you and your creations; I will start with ‘deeply impactful’.

I sense that the INDIAN KILLER also visited this place.

Love this little truth of a truth:

“stereotypes wouldn't exist if they didn't contain some truth”.

I am ready now to begin my own journey through a hard back first edition copy of BLASPHEMY.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Blasphemy! That's a lot of pages of me to read. Bring snacks and a bottle of water!

Expand full comment
James Don BlueWolf's avatar

Great read! Current, timely, a full picture beginning to end, original detail and a Native bent--what more could we want? Yakoke again, Sherman.

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Evans's avatar

Tracking the route to the small town...priceless. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank you, Elizabeth.

Expand full comment
Facundo Rompehuevos's avatar

Life is also better when you stay away from sheriffs in general! jk, dope story.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Hahahahhaha!

Expand full comment