64 Comments

Wow!!! what a story to read. Nailed it, sir! Yes you did!

Expand full comment

The man I loved until he died at 58 wasn't an Indian but he was something like the Indian man in your fictional story. We met as 17 year olds. He served in the war in Vietnam during the year we turned 21. There was something he had done that he believed was unforgivable, something he believed he would go to hell for, something that he believed he could never tell anyone. It was not clear whether the incident happened during his time in Vietnam or before or after. But he was absolutely clear to me about the nature of what he had done. It was of the nature of things that he believed you have to keep to yourself always. He couldn't forgive himself. He couldn't love himself. I don't believe in Satan or hell. I believe he did. I believe that unconditional love awaits all those who can't love themselves in life. After he died, I felt his unconditional love. Still do. The man's story rings true. He knew what he did was wrong. He didn't expect mercy. And he loved.

Expand full comment

Another slam dunk from a masterful story teller. Thank you.

Expand full comment

I had a roommate I loved in the uni. I killed his religious faith and probably his future ease with his existence by talking talking talking for a whole school year. I wrote a poem about our friendship, included in my first book SIX MILE CORNER:

Fort Hill

Dogs

mammaldom’s Boston Irish

rant from porches. Park

hoodlums

glitter at us

like battered letter knives

and the white

washed monument

built

when my friend’s greatgranddad who said

“I spit upon the people” was boss

in Boston – squat

lighthouse jammed up through a doghouse

-- at least at some time since

has been

a public privy. Not

even that use mars

its now lovely

disrelation. Across

where the walls of a half-bulldozed tenement bloom

Puerto Rican reds and golds,

an accordion

solo whines

Rocco and His Brothers.

Uncut yellow

ragweed wet

with bottle glass

hides ruggedly distinct

little boy / little girl games.

My above

mentioned friend

and I sway on the one green slat

of a bench, chat-

ting, having

never found (in slight sight through mist

of the new Prudential megalith

on Washington Heights)

anyone

each the like

of the other.

Expand full comment

Really good. You have a fantastic noir voice, was reminded of Dashiel Hammett. And the note you put up, about the cousins, one a cop, the other a bank robber, was good too -- for the red noir novel that you suggest/I hope you write. Maybe this killing is the, or a, mystery at the core? And the whole thing screams "film me." Especially if the res is photogenic. I was thinking big mountains, but maybe Seminole? Anyway, very promising.

Expand full comment

My goodness

What a delightful and engrossing read. You never know where the story is going while reading but every action makes sense in retrospect. Reminds me of why I fell in love with Alexie’s writing when I stumbled upon “The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven”

This is why I spend time with Substack!

Many thanks

Expand full comment

Masterful. You’re a true genius with words. And my feelings…..

Expand full comment

Intense - I loved it.

Expand full comment

you're good....

Expand full comment

Excellent writing! I can relate to the incident with the cops and having to convince them about being the father of the child.

Expand full comment
3 hrs ago·edited 3 hrs ago

This is fantastic. Your short stories are my favorite pieces out of all your work.

I think things like this happen IRL a lot more often than people want to believe.

Expand full comment

Great story! I love all the details, like the scars in his stomach he played like a flute.

Expand full comment

Yikes!! I did not see that coming!

Expand full comment

No surprise that I couldn’t stop reading. That I believed it knowing it was a story.

The ruler I use: If it’s good, you believe a story is true.

Expand full comment
4 hrs agoLiked by Sherman Alexie

Is this a true story? And didn’t you publicly confess to a murder?

Expand full comment

I thought so too -- even though it says "fiction." Then I realized that "fiction" is another literary conceit, meant to throw off the cops.

Expand full comment
author
4 hrs ago·edited 4 hrs agoAuthor

It says fiction right there in the subtitle.

Expand full comment
4 hrs agoLiked by Sherman Alexie

Okay, I ‘m an idiot!

Expand full comment