61 Comments
User's avatar
Toni's avatar

So amazingly powerful that i feel it in my chest!

Expand full comment
Arjan Tupan's avatar

Impressive how you can put so much in just these few lines. The tragedy of generational pain, the understanding of another human.

Thank you for sharing your poems, Mr Alexie. I hope they help you find what's lost.

Expand full comment
Wil Dalton's avatar

Ouch

Expand full comment
J.'s avatar

I read your poems about your father and there's sadness but other recurring words and themes. Gentle. Love. Quiet. Never missed a basketball game.

How tragic that TB and war stole both his parents. I imagine you were aware of loving the small lonely child that lived within him along with the adult.

My father lost all his' fathers.' The several soldiers our beloved naughty nan married and lost to war, injuries, illness or just skipped out on. A comely bosom bedecked in medals on the annual ANZAC day,

I think he never knew how to love, not having felt parental care. Only survival.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Yes, he only knew survival. A great way to describe it.

Expand full comment
Kathy Ortiz's avatar

So many of us searching for the fathers. And somehow believing that their absence makes us unworthy

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Yes, it's painful and sometimes debilitating.

Expand full comment
Francie Taylor's avatar

Children arrive so ill-equipped to recognize trauma. The kids searching their father's face for answers and the six year old still searching for his parents remain bewildered. Now add the expectations of the season to arrive at bewildered disappointment. Thanks for this poem.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thanks, Francie.

Expand full comment
Steve Lovelace's avatar

I'm not sure why, but reading this poem brought Eric Burdon's song "When I Was Young" to mind". I can only imagine what it would have like to not have our Dad around on Christmas, as a kid. We've had over 50 Christmas's since he died, I know that pain.

Expand full comment
Kate Bradley's avatar

Oh, Sherman. The world would be such a more peaceful place if people understood like you do that the important thing in our individual lives is to face our pain and transform it as best we can. I am so grateful for your sharing your gifts and strengths with us.

Expand full comment
Tina Stolberg's avatar

Ironically, I was taken back by what seemed, at first, an abrupt ending. I had expected more to follow and it took a beat to realize but maybe that's the point. Some stories aren't tied up in neat bows, and endings happen before we are ready.

Wishing you a new season of stories you alone can create out of the endings, Sherman. Thanks for giving us all the gift of your "gift."

Expand full comment
Imola's avatar

This short poem says so much... heartbreaking how trauma can be passed on, even with the best efforts of trying to create a different narrative. It is my daily struggle as a mother. Thank you for sharing. Thank you for speaking about the pain with such raw honesty. And thank you for creating beauty from this pain. What a gift your poems are! May you have a peaceful Christmas.

Expand full comment
Terrell's avatar

That is a long and often fruitless search.

Expand full comment
Amanda Wald Rachie's avatar

The sorrow of war took a toll on your lost father and your family and so many fathers and mothers and children throughout history. To this day. What comes to mind is the daily drinking of my grandfather who served as a doctor in World War I in France and died in the spring of the year World War II ended. This poem honors the experience of all those affected by war and the alcoholism that often accompanies that experience. Thank you, Sherman.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Yeah, my siblings were raised by a war orphan. The bullet that killed our paternal grandfather also critically wounded our father and seriously wounded us kids.

Expand full comment
Terrell's avatar

A measured perspective, and truly said. 🤙🏼

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank you, Terrell.

Expand full comment
Shelah Horvitz's avatar

Wow. Good poem. Multigenerational trauma. So widespread, and it just goes on and on.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank yoi, Shelah.

Expand full comment
Magpie Mama's avatar

Hugs for the hard stuff, present and past.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Thank you.

Expand full comment
william Ponder's avatar

The long dark winter of Christmas and yes, its a wonderful time but still we mourn the lost of those we love

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Yea, we miss them. And Merry Christmas to you and your new love!

Expand full comment
william Ponder's avatar

Thanks Sherman, life is good these days.

Expand full comment
Sunny Hochberg's avatar

Oh, this must make the holidays bittersweet, and sometimes just bitter. Toast us my late husband’s birthday and I’m now a Jewish Buddhist but it’s still bittersweet! And parties to savor with friends and family. It’s a lot. I hope you and yours have a lovely celebration.

Expand full comment
Sherman Alexie's avatar

Yeah, as time goes on, though, my good memories I've created with my wife and sons have more power than my difficult childhood.

Expand full comment
Sunny Hochberg's avatar

I just read this and it makes me happy! Happy New Year to you and your family. I love your work and celebrate your success through the efforts you have made.

Expand full comment